Händel - Theodora, in concert at the Salle Gaveau in Paris
Salle Gaveau, Paris
Friday November 13 2026
Conductor: Christophe Rousset. Theodora: Marie Lys. Irene: Alice Coote. Didymus: Iestyn Davies. Septimius: Guy Cutting. Valens: John Chest. The Monteverdi Choir. The English Baroque Soloists.
The last time I went to the Salle Gaveau it was to hear the Loewenguth Quartet. That won’t mean much to many people these days: the ensemble disbanded in 1983. You get my drift. Gaveau hasn’t really been ‘on my radar,’ as people say, since and it was only because a friend asked me if I was going to be there that I caught wind of this concert at all, and decided to buy tickets.
That was a no-brainer, which in my case, as you can see, is just as well. Christophe Rousset has long been my favourite among the French-based ‘baroqueux’. Ever alert, neither too approximate, too frothy, nor, on the contrary, too brutal, lively but not manic, exaggerated, mannered or outright eccentric… to me, with the signature bounce and spring and consummate musicianship he brings to his performances, Rousset is the Goldilocks of them all: just right - in Rameau especially.
Meanwhile, across the Channel, the English Baroque Soloists and the Monteverdi Choir (usually of course, until recently, under Gardiner, if we’re still allowed to mention that) have long represented to me a sort of gold standard in Händel playing. I was intrigued by the idea of such a consummate specialist in the pre-romantic French repertoire conducting Händel with the Brits - not realising (yes, I know, I miss a lot) that Rousset’s relationship with them had already led to a new recording of the 1752 Covent Garden version of Messiah (with Ana Vieira Leite, Dame Sarah Connolly, Andrew Staples and William Thomas, issued last month). The Gaveau cast looked promising. So, along I went.
![]() |
| Photo by Paul Mark Mitchell |
I hadn't heard the choir live, my blog reminds me, since Le Freischutz, i.e. the French version of Weber’s masterpiece, with recitatives by Berlioz, at the Opéra Comique in 2011. (That was with the Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique in the pit.) So I wasn’t quite prepared, fifteen years on, for how all-round fabulous they are. Perfectly in tune, perfectly together, beautifully blended, beautifully phrased, alive to the text, always crisp and understandable (unlike some on stage)... Not only are they a choir you can actually name on hearing, but most remarkably they sound exactly the same now, despite the obvious turnover since, as on their 1976 recording of Queen Mary’s Funeral Music.
My neighbour, the aforementioned friend and I all agreed: when they weren’t singing, you just sat waiting for when they next would be. I hadn’t heard choral singing at this level since the choir of Trinity College Cambridge visited Paris two or three years ago. They outshone the soloists and even the marvellous orchestra.
This concert was one stop in what looks like quite a punishing, whirlwind tour. On November 2nd the group were in Buenos Aires, on the 4th in Montevideo, on 6th in Lima, on 8th in São Paulo… The orchestra and chorus showed no particular sign of fatigue, but perhaps the soloists were, by the time they reached Paris, beginning to wonder what they’d got themselves into (before also going on to Rome, Oxford and London). It looks like cuts had been made between Latin America and Paris: Gaveau’s website had announced a duration of 3 hours 30 minutes, but in the foyer, on the cast lists posted on the walls, that was already down to 2 hours 55, and in the end, I’m not sure we even got that. More expert reviewers will probably tell us exactly what was snipped out.
Also, I wondered if the soloists realised they were upstaged by the chorus and orchestra, and found it disheartening, but that’s probably just fantasy on my part. Whatever, in the first half, though the solo singing was fair to very good, it wouldn’t knock anybody’s socks off. Things improved, however, after half time. Perhaps they’d sucked orange slices and had an invigorating rub-down in the changing rooms.
![]() |
| Photo: Eric Larrayadieu on georgetowner.com |
In any case, as Irene, now-veteran Alice Coote seemed determined to wake things up. I’d only seen her in person twice before. In a pretty awful 2006 production of Giulio Cesare (also under Christophe Rousset) she was, I declared, ‘best of all.’ A decade later she was an energetic and ‘thrilling’ Composer in concert with Kaufmann and Amber Wagner. Though now with at least three timbres (sometimes channelling Marilyn Horne, sometimes, curiously, Renee Fleming, sometimes, in remarkably daring pianissimi, Dame Janet Baker), maybe more, hers was the most dramatic, urgent performance, however bumpy, of the evening. Come to think of it, a friend in the UK, knowing I was set to see her on Friday evening, had texted me: ‘They just unleash her onto an audience and she does everything right through sheer instinct and charisma.’
John Chest is a pleasant, light American baritone. He sang Valens the last time I heard Theodora, at the Théâtre des Champs Elysées, where I found he ‘lacked force lower down and the black, villainous oomph needed in this kind of “Händelian angry man” part.’ He hasn’t developed into a bass since - but ‘where are the basses?’ has become a familiar cry of anguish these days. Guy Cutting (Septimius) is an equally pleasant, nuanced English tenor with (like Iestyn Davies: see below) the typical Oxbridge choral background, but our socks still stayed on.
Iestyn Davies’s also pleasant, even alto as Didymus probably needs no introduction. As he’s been kept busy in the US, I haven’t actually seen him often - only, like Coote twice - most recently as Tolomeo (2024), a ‘bad-boy’ role I thought he was temperamentally unsuited to, and before that, of course, more memorably in Written on Skin. He was possibly most affected by the demands of the tour. He seemed understated to me, his diction was foggy (I could barely understand a word, and Gaveau had no titles up), and unless it was my imagination, at least once discreetly stifled a cough.
I know the rising Swiss soprano Marie Lys (Theodora), though new to me, already has some fans in my entourage. Her voice, while not large, is supple, variegated and expressive. The friend I mentioned above found she fiddled around too much with her intonation, but to me that was part of the suppleness and expressiveness, so it didn't bother me - though again, however good she may have been, and she was, I still had my socks on.
Christophe Rousset has clearly built a good rapport with the orchestra and chorus. He brought all the qualities I listed above, at the start of this post, to their playing and singing, injecting, when appropriate, a playful rhythmic jauntiness and some distinctly French sounds into the proceedings. But still, at the final whistle - which came too soon for me, though dinner was certainly calling - the player of the match was the Monteverdi Choir. They can come back whenever they like, and blast the socks right off the lot of us, the more often the better.
Here, to end, is a clip from the new Messiah:



Comments
Post a Comment